In addition to the various Garrett/Johnson marriages that you mentioned in your original post, a Clevars/Cluverius
Duke of
Louisa Co., VA married a Lucy
Smith (about 1770) and then an Elizabeth
Barbour JOHNSON (about 1778). Also, a Richard
JOHNSON (do you know if he was a descendant of one of the earlier male Johnsons who had married into the
Garrett family?) married an Ann
Smith in the home of the above Mr. Duke....probably around 1772 or so. I SUSPECT that this Richard
JOHNSON and Elizabeth
Barbour JOHNSON were at least related to the Johnsons who married into the
Garrett family in some way...and I also SUSPECT that the Lucy
Smith who married Mr. Duke was related to the Ann
Smith who married Richard
JOHNSON.
In 1773, the above Richard
JOHNSON (again....was he perhaps a Johnson/Garrett descendant?) and his wife Ann
Smith had a daughter named Elizabeth "Betsy"
JOHNSON, and that daughter was baptized in
Caroline Co., VA (versus
Louisa County) in 1774. Surety was provided by a Mrs. John Thilman and her daughter Fanny Thilman of Carloine Co., VA, and research now indicates that Mrs. John Thilman was born Miss Anna Daniel (born early-1740s), and that she was a daughter of
Garrett Daniel and Clara
Smith of
Middlesex Co., VA.
Note: While I have Clara Smith's lineage back to the Alexander
Smith who lived in Lancaster/Middlesex Co., VA by at least 1650s, I do not know how/if Ann Smith....nor the above Lucy Smith....were related to Clara
Smith. In addition, while there are some very skilled and dedicated researchers of the referenced Daniel family, none of them has been able to determine a "specific reason" why
Garrett Daniel had his given name of "
Garrett."
Note: John Thilman's step-mother was a Vivion, and the
Smith and the Vivion families in
Middlesex Co., VA had intermarried earlier. So....there appears to have been a couple of "connections" between the Thilman and
Smith families.
I note that one of the daughters of William
Garrett, Sr. and Miss
Ashton married a Mr. Terrell/Terrill, and it appears that he was also associated with
Caroline Co., VA (per some records that I have seen). Did Mr. Terrell and his
Garrett wife also live in
Caroline Co., VA? Was there a "connection" of some sort between the
Garretts in
Louisa Co., VA and the
Garretts in the
Essex, Middlesex and/or
Caroline Co., VA areas?
There was Henry
Garrett who purchased land in
Middlesex Co., VA from a nephew (John
Smith) of the above Mrs. Clara (
Smith) Daniel in 1799 (I do not know where this Henry
Garrett was living prior to 1798/1799...but there had been no
Garretts at all listed on the 1783
Middlesex Co., VA tax list). In 1798/1799, that Henry
Garrett was a witness when the widow Mrs. Winifred "
Winnie"
Bennett married her second husband in
Middlesex Co., VA. Mrs. Winnie
Bennett had a son who was named
Smith Bennett, and I am trying to determine Winnie's "exact connection" to the
Smith family. Winnie had a daughter who was named Mary
Bennett, and it strongly appears that Mary
Bennett and her husband John Brown took-in an orphaned son of the above John
Smith (again, John
Smith was a nephew of Clara
Smith) around 1818-1819. This orphaned son was then named
Smith W. Brown (though DNA testing on one of his living male "Brown" descendant proves that he was a "blood
Smith" who was out of the family of the above-referenced Alexander
Smith, Clara
Smith, John
Smith, etc.), and he was my maternal gg-grandfather.
My gg-grandfather
Smith W. "Brown" married Susan Hill
Garrett, a daughter of Richard
Garrett and Nancy
Taff, in 1841 in
Middlesex Co., VA, so I am a
Garrett descendant (though I don't know if my overall
Garrett family was part of your overall
Garrett family). It APPEARS that the above Richard
Garrett had come into
Middlesex Co., VA from King and
Queen Co., VA by 1812.
Note: There was what appears to me to have been a DIFFERENT man who was named Richard JohnSton/Johnson, and he married Dorothy
Waller. Some records show that this man married second the above Ann Smith...but I now SUSPECT that two different (and possibly unrelated) Richard JohnStons/Johnsons have been incorrectly "intermixed."
Anyway, if you have any evidence that the Richard
JOHNSON who married Ann
Smith in the
Louisa Co., VA home of Mr. Duke (probably around 1772 or so)....and who then lived in
Caroline Co., VA....was a son of one of the male Johnson/female
Garrett couples, please let me know. Thanks.